At Yale, Democracy Stops at Phelps Gate

uTN Social - Free Speech Social Media

Old Campus at Yale University in New Haven, Conn., in 2012. (Michelle McLoughlin/Reuters)

The trustees should hold genuinely free and fair elections, instead of offering alumni a choice between Handpicked Candidate A and Handpicked Candidate B.

The trustees of Yale University have made it clear that they love democracy — as long as they don’t have to abide by it themselves. Democracy for thee; unaccountable governance for me. In the last couple weeks, the Yale Corporation has purged even the slightest hints of accountability from their “election system.”


One of us, Garry, is a lifelong dissident from the USSR and Russia. The other, Uriel, is a proud alumnus of Yale University — admittedly less proud today than he was a month ago. Uriel attended Yale, loved Yale, and even founded an organization there — the Peace and Dialogue Leadership Initiative — to help contribute to campus life and learning. But we all have an obligation to speak out against anti-democratic actions, especially when they happen at home. Now as the chairman and the executive director, respectively, of the Renew Democracy Initiative, we must respond to threats to democratic norms regardless of where they originate.

Elections to the Yale Corporation are a byzantine, opaque process. Most candidates apply through the Alumni Fellow Nominating Committee. These applicants are not allowed to campaign, reveal their policy positions, or even talk about what they would do if elected. The committee then reveals its endorsed candidates just 24 to 48 hours before voting begins — an election in name only.


However, in order to lay claim to some element of democracy, Yale allowed outside candidates to run by petition if they received at least 4,500 alumni signatures (3 percent of all living alumni). This past year, two petition candidates managed to clear that hurdle: Maggie Thomas, a progressive Democrat, and Victor Ashe, a conservative Republican. Both ran on increasing accountability for the Yale Corporation. Thomas, a climate-policy expert, campaigned to divest from fossil fuels. Meanwhile, Ashe questioned the Yale Corporation’s current policy of sealing all minutes for at least 50 years and called for a repeal to Yale’s “gag rule.” Thomas later dropped out and Ashe lost.

But it seems that, despite his electoral loss, Ashe’s calls for a minimal amount of transparency spooked the trustees of Yale. So, on May 24, 2021, they announced that new rules would prohibit any candidates in future elections from running on petitions not approved by the university. The three petition campaigns already announced for next year are now a moot point. Sorry, kids, no glasnost or perestroika for you!


In a statement explaining their decision, the trustees attacked the very concept of democracy. In particular, they criticized “issues-based candidacies,” an interesting argument for a group purporting to support the democratic process. If we don’t vote on “issues,” what criteria should we use — best hairdo? The letter described, in horror, “a new normal in which every election saw vying groups with organized support competing to focus Yale on their chosen goals.” Please insert your own gasps. This sentence would not feel out of place if it had been uttered by Viktor Orban or Andrzej Duda.

The Yale Corporation’s hypocrisy in this statement is particularly galling. The Ivy League scions who make up this committee regularly lecture the rest of America about the importance of democracy from the comfort of their C-suite offices.

NR Daily is delivered right to you every afternoon. No charge.

Get Jim Geraghty’s tour of the political news of the day.

Get Kevin D. Williamson’s newsletter delivered to your inbox each Tuesday.

A weekly digest on business and economics from an NR sensibility.

Yet for all their ostensible outrage, when thousands of alumni exercised the democratic rights enshrined in Yale’s regulations, the trustees were so worried about the outcome that they decided to quietly kill the democratic process itself. Either Yale’s trustees stand for democracy or they don’t. If they do, then they should hold genuinely free and fair elections, instead of offering a choice between Handpicked Candidate A and Handpicked Candidate B. They should repeal the “gag rule” and publish their minutes in a timely fashion, instead of 50 years later, once everyone at that meeting is dead and safely buried. And they need to prioritize democratic processes rather than a specific preferred outcome.

Democracy is a muscle. Without exercise, it will atrophy and die. Yale trustee elections might seem irrelevant to most Americans (and most Yale alumni), but we all know the importance of defending democracy. We cannot criticize authoritarian leaders abroad while forgoing democratic processes at home, and we cannot expect our national leaders to prioritize democracy if the educational institutions where they studied don’t offer them a chance to practice what they preach.


Garry Kasparov is a former chess world champion, best-selling author, and the chairman of the Renew Democracy Initiative. Uriel Epshtein is a Yale alumnus, business strategist, and the executive director of the Renew Democracy Initiative.


The Coming Backlash against Woke Public Schools

Parents have had enough of the politicization of their local schools. And even if the schools themselves can’t see it yet, they will soon.

The Lab-Leak Theory: Evidence Beyond a Reasonable Doubt

Every good prosecutor will tell you that the best case is a strong circumstantial case — and that’s exactly what we have.

The Problems with Laurel Hubbard’s Qualifying for the Olympics as a Woman

The New Zealand weightlifter, who was born and competed as a male, has clear advantages over female competitors.

A Grad Student Tried to Correct a Misleading COVID Narrative. Rebekah Jones Tried to Ruin His Career for It

Jon Taylor had a disagreement with Jones over COVID data, so she falsely accused him of sexual harassment.

The Breaking of Stephen Colbert

The demands of nightly doses of craven partisanship for year upon year have ruined him.

Maggie Haberman Is Right

Donald Trump really does believe that he, along with two former GOP senators, will be ‘reinstated’ to office this summer.

The Latest

A Currency Board Would Bring Lebanon Back from the Dead

It’s a necessary first step to facilitate needed reforms that can save Lebanon from becoming a failed state under Iran’s control.

Witness from Syria

Under siege in Aleppo, Waad al-Kateab took a camera and filmed. And filmed. And filmed.

A.I. Is the Best Film of the 21st Century

Spielberg’s prescient epic of faith remains miraculous.

The Bad-Sex Blockbuster

Fifty years later, Carnal Knowledge remains a brilliant, lacerating tour de force.

When New York Times Fake News Replaces American History

Truthful discussions never begin with lies. The 1619 Project is founded on a lie. It has no place in our nation’s schools.

Modern Ecoterrorism: From Bougie LARPers to the Biden Administration

Biden’s BLM nominee once advocated the ecoterrorism and population-control methods too many modern environmentalists prefer over genuine stewardship.

Top Stories

Get our conservative analysis delivered right to you. No charge.

Most Popular

The Rise of Equity Charges at Restaurants

The Rise of Equity Charges at Restaurants

Telling your customers you are going to begin charging them more because they are too bigoted to tip fairly might not be a winning restaurant strategy.

Eric Adams Says Vote Counting Raises ‘Serious Questions’ after Losing Ground In NYC Mayor’s Race

Eric Adams Says Vote Counting Raises ‘Serious Questions’ after Losing Ground In NYC Mayor’s Race

The candidate demanded the board explain apparent discrepancies in the most recent dump of ranked-choice voting results.

Joe Biden Is Leaving Kamala Harris In a No-Win Situation

Joe Biden Is Leaving Kamala Harris In a No-Win Situation

Now it’s no longer beyond the pale to point out that Joe Biden is leaving Kamala Harris to handle all of his no-win situations.

View More

Read More Feedzy

The Foxhole App - Trusted News Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *