Garry Wills Is Wrong about the Bishops and Abortion

uTN Social - Free Speech Social Media

Pope Francis in Camerino, Italy, June 16, 2019 (Remo Casilli/Reuters)

As Michael Brendan Dougherty ably noted on the Corner a bit earlier, the New York Times opinion page has published its latest piece attempting to make it appear as if pro-life Catholics don’t understand their own religion.

Prominent historian Garry Wills has been studying the Catholic Church and its history for far longer than I have, so I know he cannot claim ignorance as a defense for having published an op-ed that so grotesquely manipulates the facts in order to defend legal abortion.


Wills begins from the premise that Catholic bishops in the United States are doing something that, in reality, no one is doing: “trying to deny the reception of Holy Communion by the president of the United States for not working to prevent [abortion].”

As Wills surely knows, the complaint of Catholics and their leaders is not that Biden fails to prevent abortion but rather that he actively promotes abortion — legal until birth and funded by taxpayers — while continuing to profess the faith of the Catholic Church, which has for centuries condemned the taking of all innocent human life.

But, it turns out, Wills is not so sure that an unborn child is a human life, after all. He asserts that his own “clipped fingernails or trimmed hairs are human life,” as if the fact that his body generates human cells somehow negates an unborn child’s own fingernails, hair, heartbeat, and indeed entire genetic code, totally distinct from both mother and father.

Meanwhile, later in the piece, he offers a sloppy defense of abortion that would fit better in a freshman dorm room than in the pages of the Times: the claim that “at least half of the fertilized eggs fail to . . . [adhere] to the uterus.” In Wills’s view, this makes God guiltier than the abortionist, if we believe an unborn child has moral worth.

NR Daily is delivered right to you every afternoon. No charge.

Get Jim Geraghty’s tour of the political news of the day.

Get Kevin D. Williamson’s newsletter delivered to your inbox each Tuesday.

A weekly digest on business and economics from an NR sensibility.

We’ll deliver The Capital Note to your inbox each weekday. No charge.

Wills can defend abortion, if he must, but he isn’t entitled to hand-wave away biology with arguments as sophomoric as these.

Elsewhere, he lambastes “the cult of the fetus,” pointing out that some women don’t take pains to bury their unborn child after a miscarriage, and indeed that the Catholic Church itself doesn’t require it. But that doesn’t negate the humanity of the unborn child, much less serve as a defense of deliberate efforts to kill her.


Along the way, Wills botches several key facts, ascribing views to Sts. Augustine and Thomas Aquinas that they did not profess and claiming that the Church has abandoned all efforts to root its defense of human life in Sacred Scripture — an assertion easily disproven by a quick skim of relevant portions of the Catechism.

In closing, Wills bizarrely insists that Pope Francis is “on the side” of women who “have had abortions and still consider themselves Catholics.” The pope surely believes, as all Catholics do, in the love and mercy of God, in the reality of repentance, forgiveness, and redemption, so in one sense Wills is correct. But his claim isn’t true in the way he means it. Though progressives prefer to pretend otherwise, Pope Francis has spoken out consistently and forcefully in defense of unborn human life, and the Catholic bishops have every reason to do the same.


The Problems with Laurel Hubbard’s Qualifying for the Olympics as a Woman

The New Zealand weightlifter, who was born and competed as a male, has clear advantages over female competitors.

The Lab-Leak Theory: Evidence Beyond a Reasonable Doubt

Every good prosecutor will tell you that the best case is a strong circumstantial case — and that’s exactly what we have.

The Fall of Saint Anthony Fauci

On the unforced errors of America’s most political doctor.

A Grad Student Tried to Correct a Misleading COVID Narrative. Rebekah Jones Tried to Ruin His Career for It

Jon Taylor had a disagreement with Jones over COVID data, so she falsely accused him of sexual harassment.

The Breaking of Stephen Colbert

The demands of nightly doses of craven partisanship for year upon year have ruined him.

Maggie Haberman Is Right

Donald Trump really does believe that he, along with two former GOP senators, will be ‘reinstated’ to office this summer.

The Latest

There Is No Conservative Case for Blowing Up the Filibuster

Nuke-the-filibuster advocates argue that the GOP can reverse bad laws when they come to power. Except they almost never do. See: Obamacare.

FBI Lawyer Who Doctored Russiagate Email Agrees to One-Year Law License Suspension

The former FBI lawyer could be prohibited from practicing law again until August 2021.

Federal Court Dismisses FTC Antitrust Suit against Facebook

The Federal Trade Commission accused Facebook of engaging in ‘anticompetitive’ practices.

Biden Admin Defends BLM Nominee Despite Link to Eco-Terrorism, Support for Population Control

The White House said Stone-Manning is ‘exceptionally qualified’ to lead the Bureau of Land Management.

Another Round of Fake Florida News

Journalists have accused DeSantis of throttling the condo-collapse-emergency response.

Unemployment Rolls Shrinking Faster in States That Opted Out of Enhanced Federal Benefits

In all, 22 states have opted out of enhanced federal unemployment benefits.

Top Stories

Get our conservative analysis delivered right to you. No charge.

Most Popular

Where’s the Equity for Black Murder Victims?

Where’s the Equity for Black Murder Victims?

That the disproportionate number of black murder victims doesn’t exercise progressives more remains one of the paradoxes of our time.

Trump at First Rally Since Leaving Office: ‘We Won’

Trump at First Rally Since Leaving Office: ‘We Won’

In his first campaign-style rally since leaving the White House, former President Donald Trump still insisted he won the election ‘in a landslide.’

Supreme Court Declines to Take Up Transgender Bathroom Case, Leaving in Place Victory for Trans Student

Supreme Court Declines to Take Up Transgender Bathroom Case, Leaving in Place Victory for Trans Student

The decision leaves in place a lower court’s ruling that the Virginia school board discriminated against the student.

View More

Read More Feedzy

The Foxhole App - Trusted News Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *