Judge Finds California Gig-Worker Law Unconstitutional in Blow to Uber, Lyft

uTN Social - Free Speech Social Media

Uber and Lyft drivers protest during a day-long strike outside Uber’s office in Saugus, Massachusetts, U.S., May 8, 2019. (Brian Snyder/Reuters)

A California judge on Friday struck down a 2020 ballot measure that allowed Uber and Lyft to classify their gig workers as independent contractors, allowing them to deny said workers full-time benefits.

After Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, InstaCart, and Postmates reportedly spent over $200 million lobbying for the measure, known as Proposition 22, Alameda County Superior Court Judge Frank Roesch ruled that the “entirety” of the measure is “unenforceable.”


Roesch explained in his ruling that this is because a section within Prop 22 “limits the power of a future legislature to define app-based drivers as workers subject to workers’ compensation law” and “is not severable” from the rest of the measure.

The judge said a section of the proposition that requires a seven-eighth’s legislative majority for amendments to pass is in violation of the state’s constitution.

“A prohibition on legislation authorizing collective bargaining by app-based drivers does not promote the right to work as an independent contractor, nor does it protect work flexibility, nor does it provide minimum workplace safety and pay standards for those workers,” Roesch wrote in his ruling.

“It appears only to protect the economic interest of the network companies in having a divided, ununionized workforce, which is not a stated goal of the legislation,” he added.

NR Daily is delivered right to you every afternoon. No charge.

Get Jim Geraghty’s tour of the political news of the day.

Get Kevin D. Williamson’s newsletter delivered to your inbox each Tuesday.

A weekly digest on business and economics from an NR sensibility.

A coalition representing the gig economy companies said Friday that it will appeal the ruling.

“We will file an immediate appeal and are confident the Appellate Court will uphold Prop 22,” said Geoff Vetter, spokesperson for the Protect App-Based Drivers & Services Coalition. “Importantly, this Superior Court ruling is not binding and will be immediately stayed upon our appeal. All of the provisions of Prop 22 will remain in effect until the appeal process is complete.”

The decision comes in response to a lawsuit first filed in January in California’s Supreme Court by labor union Service Employees International Union (SEIU), three ride-hail drivers, and one ride-hail customer. The plaintiffs hoped to overturn Prop 22 before being refiled in lower court.


California voters, in voting for Prop 22 in November, overturned a state labor law that had made it easier to classify drivers as employees rather than as independent contractors. The proposition, which passed by referendum with 58.6 percent of the vote, was the companies’ response to state labor law Assembly Bill 5 which created an “ABC” test to assess if workers are employees who are eligible for labor protections and benefits.

Prop 22 allowed the ride-sharing and delivery companies to treat drivers as independent contractors while conceding certain benefits to some drivers, but not all of the protections that workers would have received without the measure. The law allowed the companies to continue to deny the drivers full-employment status, including benefits such as sick pay, health care and minimum wage.

Bob Schoonover, president of SEIU California State Council, said in a statement that the ruling “couldn’t be clearer” that the “gig-industry-funded ballot initiative was unconstitutional and is therefore unenforceable.”



“Companies like Uber and Lyft spent $225 million in an effort to take away rights from workers in a way that violates California’s Constitution,” he added.

“They tried to boost their profits by undermining democracy and the state constitution. For two years, drivers have been saying that democracy cannot be bought. And today’s decision shows they were right,” he continued.

Send a tip to the news team at NR.


House Democrats Pass Bill to Pay for Abortions around the Globe with U.S. Tax Dollars

If Democrats push forward with that proposal, it could ultimately fall to West Virginia Democratic senator Joe Manchin to determine its passage.

The Biden Illusion Crumbles to Dust

President Joe Biden addressed the nation and confirmed all of the worst suspicions of his critics.

The Biden Blowout Is Just Beginning

These days, a trillion-dollar spending bill is a trifle barely worth arguing over and the stuff of bipartisan consensus.

Joe Manchin Just Blew Up Rationale for Republicans to Cut an Infrastructure Deal

Manchin has made clear that any Republican that votes for the bipartisan charade is greasing the wheels for Democrats to ram through their entire agenda.

When You Understand What Happened to Simone Biles, It Makes Sense

There are things you can play through, and things you shouldn’t.

A Misleading Narrative about the Unvaccinated

You don’t have to look far on social media to find people contending that the remaining unvaccinated are overwhelmingly Republicans.

The Latest

Pompeo Slams Biden State Department for Dissolving Crisis Response Bureau as Taliban Advanced

‘The Biden administration made the determination that they’re going to just throw it all away,’ Pompeo said.

The Forever War Isn’t Over

The Afghan debacle just marks a new, more murderous phase.

America Has Been in Denial about the Taliban from the Start

For 20 years, some of us have been countering that you can’t defeat the enemy without understanding that they are the enemy, and what they believe.

Joe Biden Is Who We Said He Was

Nobody should, any longer, pretend that Joe Biden is fit to lead this nation.

A First-Rate Weather Vane Show at the American Folk Art Museum

American Weathervanes: The Art of the Winds exhibition at the American Folk Art Museum has the wind at its back in quality and fun.

Private Firms Are the Key to Space Exploration

To kick-start Mars exploration, use a money prize to incentivize enterprise.

Top Stories

Get breaking news, with NR’s unfiltered reporting, delivered straight to your inbox

Most Popular

Something Is Wrong with the President

Something Is Wrong with the President

Biden’s latest interview, insistence that he was incorrectly briefed, and low profile amid the Afghanistan crisis all raise troubling questions.

No American Military Leader Should Ever Say What Lloyd Austin Said

No American Military Leader Should Ever Say What Lloyd Austin Said

Can you imagine Norman Schwarzkopf — to say nothing of Dwight Eisenhower or Douglas MacArthur — making this statement?

The True Extent of Biden’s Lies about Afghanistan

The True Extent of Biden’s Lies about Afghanistan

New revelations on Afghanistan reveal how many things President Biden said in recent days that were the precise opposite of the truth.

View More

Read More Feedzy

The Foxhole App - Trusted News Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *