Mississippi’s Case against <em>Roe</em>

uTN Social - Free Speech Social Media

The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C., July 2, 2020 (Jonathan Ernst/Reuters)

Lynn Fitch, the attorney general of Mississippi, gets right to the point in the state’s legal brief in defense of its ban on abortions after 15 weeks’ gestation:

On a sound understanding of the Constitution, the answer to the question presented in this case is clear and the path to that answer is straight. Under the Constitution, may a State prohibit elective abortions before viability? Yes. Why? Because nothing in constitutional text, structure, history, or tradition supports a right to abortion. A prohibition on elective abortions is therefore constitutional if it satisfies the rational-basis review that applies to all laws.

The two obstacles in that path are Roe v. Wade and Casey v. Planned Parenthood, which ignored text, structure, history — ignored the Constitution nearly completely — to pretend that abortion requires the federal courts to extend it special protection. Fitch and her colleagues explain patiently and thoroughly why those obstacles should be removed. The decisions were “egregiously wrong.” They have inflicted harm to self-government. They have not resulted in the stable consensus the Court has repeatedly sought and predicted. They have rested on premises about the reliability of contraception, the career prospects of women, and the state of medicine that no longer apply if they ever did. These outdated premises are at the heart of the Court’s previous findings about women’s “reliance” on constitutionalized abortion rights.

And they have proven incapable of generating a predictable body of law. The brief notes that just last year, the five justices who agreed to strike down an abortion regulation could not agree on the basis for doing it, and the five justices who agreed on what Casey meant did not reach the same judgment in the case. The justices’ inability to devise a predictable set of rules that protects abortion from legislatures, gives them some leeway to set policy, and has some plausible grounding in the Constitution does not stem from any lack of cleverness on their part. The thing cannot be done.

When the Court handed down Casey in 1992, it tacitly conceded many of the faults of Roe while insisting that the need to preserve public respect for itself as an institution required it to stick with the pretense that the Constitution protects abortion. Fitch gently but firmly observes that after nearly 30 years, this judgment has proven spectacularly wrong. It is the Court’s extraconstitutional role in setting abortion policy, more than anything else, that has diminished and distorted it.

The justices may duck this argument but cannot refute it. The Constitution, federalism, the separation of powers, and moral truth all converge on an answer in this case, and Mississippi has just identified it. The justices should have the courage and integrity to admit that the Court has been wrong.

Recommended


An Olympic Weightlifter Speaks Out on the Participation of Transgender Athletes in Women’s Sports

There are two sides to every story, and Tracey Lambrechs is here to tell the other.


Biden’s ‘Double Death Tax’

The White House is proposing what would amount to a second estate tax. The one we already have is bad enough.


American Men Suffer a Friendship Recession

American men have fewer friends than in decades past. We should dedicate time to fostering friendships. They provide an immediate and enduring reward.


Lindsey Graham Is an Idiot

Democrats are treating the infrastructure and reconciliation bills as linked, and so should Republicans and everybody else.


The Problems with Laurel Hubbard’s Qualifying for the Olympics as a Woman

The New Zealand weightlifter, who was born and competed as a male, has clear advantages over female competitors.


The Kids Are Not Alright: Chaos at the College Republican National Committee

College Republican chapters all over the country claim they are being disenfranchised by a president seeking to consolidate power.

The Latest


Pelosi Touts ‘Devout’ Catholicism and Big Family, Says Abortion about ‘Fairness’ for Poor Women

The House speaker revealed her opinion on abortion in a similar way at a June briefing.


Psaki Suggests Short-Staffed Businesses ‘Pay More Wages’ to ‘Attract Workers’

Psaki did not address the other possible culprit: the expansion and extension of unemployment benefits in many states.


John Mayer Moves Forward by Going Back

On his latest album, Sob Rock, the virtuosic singer-songwriter-guitarist finds fresh inspiration in the music of the 1980s.


Pelosi’s Capitol-Riot-Probe Power Play Saves Republicans from Themselves

The House speaker has given GOP lawmakers legitimate cause to boycott a process in which they were poised to embarrass themselves defending President Trump.


Psaki Defends Hunter Biden’s Expected Meetings with Potential Art Buyers

Hunter won’t ‘have any conversation related to the selling of art. That will be left to the gallerist,’ Psaki said.


Missouri Teachers, CRT Advocate Plotted to Hide Social Justice Curriculum from ‘Trump Country’ Parents

Teachers can be heard on a leaked video strategizing on how best to keep parents in the dark on new social justice curriculum changes.

Top Stories

Get our conservative analysis delivered right to you. No charge.


Most Popular


The Navy’s Debauchery Problem: An Enlisted Perspective


The Navy’s Debauchery Problem: An Enlisted Perspective

Senator Tom Cotton’s report on the service branch gets a lot right about the upper ranks, but the enlisted side remains in dire need of attention.


Pope Francis Takes Aim at the Latin Mass — and His Own Faithful


Pope Francis Takes Aim at the Latin Mass — and His Own Faithful

This may be the most significant act of Francis’s pontificate; and it’s nothing more than bullying iconoclasm.


The Anthony Bourdain Mystery


The Anthony Bourdain Mystery

Why did the chef and traveler kill himself? The documentary Roadrunner: A Film about Anthony Bourdain suggests a less than satisfying answer.


View More

Read More Feedzy

The Foxhole App - Trusted News Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *