Taxing Unrealized Capital Gains: A Bad Idea That Just Won’t Die

uTN Social - Free Speech Social Media
(alfexe/Getty Images)

Vampires are — so the stories go — extremely difficult to kill, and so it’s somehow appropriate that the same is true, but in reality, of predatory tax proposals.

The Wall Street Journal

President Biden expressed support for a proposal under consideration in the Senate to place an annual income tax on billionaires’ unrealized capital gains.

The potential tax increase, being pursued by Senate Finance Chairman Ron Wyden (D., Ore.), would be among a number of tax provisions that Mr. Biden is seeking to pay for a proposed $3.5 trillion spending plan that encapsulates much of his first-term agenda. It is an alternative to some administration tax ideas that have flopped in Congress, and it would generate money from the wealthiest sliver of Americans, whose incomes can be a fraction of their wealth.

It is not unknown for a tax to begin life by being levied on “the wealthiest sliver of Americans,” but, over time, for it to catch more and more people in its web. As I wrote in March in response to a wealth tax proposed by (surprise!) Elizabeth Warren:

When a “permanent” income tax was introduced after the passing of the 16th Amendment, there were not many victims, and they didn’t suffer much. Less than 1 percent of the population paid income taxes at the rate of only 1 percent of net income. I understand that changed.

Back to the WSJ:

The idea is that for billionaires only, annual gains in wealth would be treated as income. So under current law, someone whose net worth rose to $22 billion from $20 billion and sold nothing would have no income. Under Mr. Wyden’s proposal, that person would have $2 billion of taxable income.

One challenge for the proposal is that it would need to deal with losses, and the prospect of the government sending large checks to billionaires is politically unappealing. Lawmakers could allow deductions for annual losses while also imposing limits on those deductions or allowing them to carry forward to offset gains in future years.

Mr. Wyden has been working on the idea of annual taxes on unrealized gains for several years, and its adoption would mark a significant change to U.S. tax law that would redefine taxable income for a few hundred people. It would affect billionaires such as Jeff Bezos and Warren Buffett.

There is no official revenue estimate yet, but a similar proposal targeted at a larger group—the top 0.1% of households—would raise about $750 billion over a decade, according to a 2019 estimate from tax professors Lily Batchelder and David Kamin, who are now both senior Biden administration officials.

So the first hint of the future extension of such a tax is already there. The Wyden proposal affects a “few hundred” people, but the Biden administration contains two academics (it’s always worth remembering that class warfare is primarily managed from within the elite) who had already proposed something similar for the top 0.1 percent of households, still a tiny number, but the ratchet has to start somewhere.

NR Daily is delivered right to you every afternoon. No charge.

Get Jim Geraghty’s tour of the political news of the day.

Get Kevin D. Williamson’s newsletter delivered to your inbox each Tuesday.

A weekly digest on business and economics from an NR sensibility.

The authors of the WSJ report (Ken Thomas and Richard Rubin) highlight other practical difficulties with such a tax:

The proposal would be very difficult for the Internal Revenue Service to implement and enforce, partly because of the challenge of valuing illiquid assets, said Andrew Moylan, executive vice president of the National Taxpayers Union Foundation. The resulting revenue stream could be volatile, and the proposal could make it harder for founders of large companies to maintain control….

The system doesn’t need to be perfect in addressing every complexity, and policy makers should focus on making it easy to administer and hard to avoid, said Ari Glogower, a tax law professor at Ohio State University.

“You want to design a system that’s going to raise revenue and avoid the most substantial gaming opportunities,” he said.

Translation: We need to stick it to the taxpayer.

There are plenty of other objections to taxing unrealized capital gains and, writing back in 2019, David Bahnsen responded to an earlier, broader (“millionaires and billionaires” were to be targeted) Wyden proposal with a thorough demolition job here.

I’d add this to what David had to say. A tax on an increase on unrealized (and, of course, possibly ephemeral) gains is only on the most stretched of interpretations a tax on income. In reality it is a tax on wealth, and one thing that wealth taxes do is redefine the relationship between the individual and the state. To be sure, it is “only” a tax on a portion of a wicked billionaire’s wealth, but (to repeat myself) the ratchet has to begin somewhere.

As I tweeted here:

A wealth tax is a sophisticated, lighter touch derivative of feudalism, but the core of it is the same: The state (“the king”) has, theoretically, a call on everything you own.

That’s not where we should want to be headed.


After Altercation at Restaurant, Black Lives Matter Claims NYC Vaccine Mandate Is Being Weaponized

‘Black people are not going to stand by, or you will see another uprising,’ BLM NYC co-founder says at Monday protest.

Border Patrol Outraged by Biden’s Scapegoating: ‘He Just Started a War’

‘I see the administration wants to fry our agents, he just started a war with Border Patrol,’ said one agent.

Why Aren’t Americans Protesting in the Streets?

No one seems to care that Democrats are walking us into a fiscal catastrophe.

Justice Kavanaugh Refuses to Buckle

He had to have known that voting as he did in the Texas case would bring him bad press.

The Real Story in Durham’s Indictment of Democratic Lawyer Michael Sussmann

The special counsel’s final report on the Clinton campaign’s manufacturing of the Trump–Russia collusion narrative will be very interesting reading.

The Real Biden Presidency Emerges

The heroic period of his administration was always a mirage.

The Latest

Researcher Corrects Secretary of Education after He Cites Her Study to Justify School Mask Mandates

The study was not able to say whether mask-wearing affected the low transmission rates observed in the schools.

Manchin Hammers Home Opposition to $3.5 Trillion Reconciliation Bill: ‘Fiscal Insanity’

In a statement released Wednesday, the West Virginia senator reiterated that he refuses to endorse expanding government programs of the magnitude that progressive House Democrats are proposing.

Milley Points Fingers at State Department for Botched Afghanistan Evacuation

During a closed session on Tuesday, Milley remarked that the civilian rescue effort should have been initiated earlier.

Don’t Call It a Deadline

Biden’s agenda will pass at some point if the votes exist, regardless of what happens on Thursday.

New Poll: One Piece of Bad News for Biden after Another

A new survey is loaded with grisly news of American pessimism and all sorts of hurt for the president and his party.

ABC Omits Obama’s Criticism of ‘Open Borders’ from Televised Interview

‘We’re a nation state. We have borders. The idea that we can just have open borders is something that . . . is unsustainable,’ Obama said.


Our Capital Letter email newsletter delivers a weekly digest on finance, business, and economics from an NR sensibility.

Most Popular

Psaki Responds to Obama’s Claim That Open Borders Policy Is ‘Unsustainable’

Psaki Responds to Obama’s Claim That Open Borders Policy Is ‘Unsustainable’

‘We’re a nation state. We have borders. The idea that we can just have open borders is something that…as a practical matter, is unsustainable,’ he said.

Governor Kathy Hochul Is One Weird Duck

Governor Kathy Hochul Is One Weird Duck

New York’s disconcerting new governor.

Say, How Is Joe Biden’s Memory These Days?

Say, How Is Joe Biden’s Memory These Days?

Is Joe Biden lying about the Pentagon’s advice on Afghanistan? Or can he genuinely not remember?

View More

Read More Feedzy

The Foxhole App - Trusted News Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *