This Day in Liberal Judicial Activism–August 24

uTN Social - Free Speech Social Media
(jaflippo/Getty Images)

1995–The citizen-suit provision of the Endangered Species Act authorizes “any person” to sue for violations of the ESA. Demonstrating why liberal judicial activists should be an endangered species, Ninth Circuit judge Stephen Reinhardt, joined by two other Jimmy Carter appointees (Harry Pregerson and William C. Canby, Jr.), rules in Bennett v. Plenert that the so-called “zone of interests test” that courts have developed (beyond Article III’s constitutional requirements) as a prudential limitation on standing overrides the broad language of the citizen-suit provision. Therefore, the court concludes, “plaintiffs who assert no interest in preserving endangered species”–in this case, ranch operators and irrigation districts who alleged that they would be harmed by reservoir levels designed to protect two species of sucker fish–cannot challenge violations of the ESA.

On review by the Supreme Court, not even the Clinton Administration will defend the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning. In a unanimous opinion (in Bennett v. Spear), Justice Scalia explains that the zone-of-interests test is a judicially self-imposed limit on standing that Congress is free to negate–and that Congress did so through the ESA’s citizen-suit provision.

2020–In a pair of orders (in Jones v. Shinn and Ramirez v. Shinn), the Ninth Circuit denies en banc review of panel rulings that allow Arizona prisoners on death row to pursue their federal habeas claims that their postconviction counsel in state habeas proceedings had provided constitutionally inadequate assistance. In a dissent from each order, Judge Daniel P. Collins, joined by seven of his colleagues, objects that the panel decisions “disregard controlling Supreme Court precedent by creating a new judge-made exception to the restrictions imposed by the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act on the use of new evidence in habeas corpus proceedings.”

Recommended


The Biden Illusion Crumbles to Dust

President Joe Biden addressed the nation and confirmed all of the worst suspicions of his critics.


The Biden Blowout Is Just Beginning

These days, a trillion-dollar spending bill is a trifle barely worth arguing over and the stuff of bipartisan consensus.


Joe Manchin Just Blew Up Rationale for Republicans to Cut an Infrastructure Deal

Manchin has made clear that any Republican that votes for the bipartisan charade is greasing the wheels for Democrats to ram through their entire agenda.


When You Understand What Happened to Simone Biles, It Makes Sense

There are things you can play through, and things you shouldn’t.


Newsom’s Recall Problem Is with Hispanic Voters

Two new polls show Hispanic voters, who heavily supported him in 2018, now favoring his ouster.


A Misleading Narrative about the Unvaccinated

You don’t have to look far on social media to find people contending that the remaining unvaccinated are overwhelmingly Republicans.

The Latest


U.S. Turning Away Some Afghan Allies from Kabul Airport to Give Priority to American Citizens

Some SIV’s told the Times they were turned away from the airport after being instructed to travel there.


Medical Experts, Parents Deeply Divided over Masking in Schools as Delta Surges

In the spring, Dr. Lucy McBride wrote an op-ed urging an end to masking kids. Now, as Delta surges, she’s changed her tune.


Down in Cullman, &c.

On Alabama, the vaccine wars, ballplayers, a town on Lake Michigan, and more.


The Media’s Finest Hour

Amid the Afghanistan debacle, Team Biden is caught flat-footed as, for once, a typically compliant press holds him to account.


Not Your Father’s Infrastructure

If the past five decades are any guide, the Senate infrastructure bill is unlikely to stimulate economic growth.


Michael M. Thomas, RIP

The longtime New York Observer columnist, who died on August 7, was an old-money WASP par excellence.

Top Stories

Get our conservative analysis delivered right to you. No charge.

Read More Feedzy

The Foxhole App - Trusted News Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *