This Day in Liberal Judicial Activism–August 30

uTN Social - Free Speech Social Media
(diane39/Getty Images)

1971–By a vote of 6 to 1, the California supreme court rules in Serrano v. Priest that California’s “public school financing system, with its substantial dependence on local property taxes and resultant wide disparities in school revenue, violates the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.” Specifically, “the right to an education in our public schools is a fundamental interest which cannot be conditioned on wealth,” and the state financing system “invidiously discriminates against the poor because it makes the quality of a child’s education a function of the wealth of his parents and neighbors.”

Two years later (in San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez), the U.S. Supreme Court, by a vote of 5 to 4, rejects Serrano‘s analysis, as it rules that Texas’s similar system of financing public school education does not violate equal-protection guarantees. Citing Serrano, Justice Powell’s majority opinion adds this prescient “cautionary postscript”:

[T]here is nothing simple or certain about predicting the consequences of massive change in the financing and control of public education…. The complexity of these problems is demonstrated by the lack of consensus with respect to whether it may be said with any assurance that the poor, the racial minorities, or the children in overburdened core-city school districts would be benefited by abrogation of traditional modes of financing education…. Additionally, several research projects have concluded that any financing alternative designed to achieve a greater equality of expenditures is likely to lead to higher taxation and lower educational expenditures in the major urban centers, a result that would exacerbate rather than ameliorate existing conditions in those areas.

Ah, the unintended consequences of liberal judicial activism: According to experts, the Serrano decision “overlooked the fact that 75% of poor children lived in high spending districts,” and it thus “actually led to lower school spending for most poor children” and to “equalized mediocrity.” Further, Serrano and its follow-on rulings are credited with triggering the property-tax revolt that culminated in California’s Proposition 13–“After all, the logic goes, if increased property taxes don’t help our schools, why should we be for increased property taxes”–and helped lead to Ronald Reagan’s election as president in 1980.

2006–In a front-page story in the New York Times, Supreme Court reporter Linda Greenhouse reports a “sudden drop” in the number of female law clerks for the first full year of the Roberts Court. Justice Souter, who has no female clerks for that year, attributes the reduction to random variation, but Greenhouse observes that Justice Ginsburg had considered the drop sufficiently significant to take note of it in a speech to the American Sociological Association.

Whatever Ginsburg’s sociological musings might have been, she ought to have had a keener understanding of the consequences of nondiscriminatory merit-based selection and random variation. In her 1993 Supreme Court confirmation hearing, it was learned, much to Ginsburg’s visible embarrassment, that in her 13 years on the D.C. Circuit she had never had a single black law clerk, intern, or secretary. Out of 57 employees, zero blacks.

Advertisement

Ginsburg will end up hiring only one black law clerk during her Supreme Court tenure. So over her career of more than four decades on the bench, that’s a single black law clerk out of her total of 150 or so law clerks.

Recommended


CENTCOM Commander Reveals U.S. Intelligence-Sharing Operation with Taliban

The U.S. reportedly provided the Taliban with a list of U.S. citizens, green card holders, and Afghan allies.


Worse Than Saigon

In yielding Afghanistan to the Taliban, Joe Biden has engineered the worst foreign-policy disaster in a generation.


The Biden Illusion Crumbles to Dust

President Joe Biden addressed the nation and confirmed all of the worst suspicions of his critics.


The Biden Blowout Is Just Beginning

These days, a trillion-dollar spending bill is a trifle barely worth arguing over and the stuff of bipartisan consensus.


Newsom’s Recall Problem Is with Hispanic Voters

Two new polls show Hispanic voters, who heavily supported him in 2018, now favoring his ouster.


The Imminent, Inevitable Taliban Victory

Twenty years, and we are still where we were on September 10, 2001.

The Latest


The Afghan Disaster

Notes on a war, a withdrawal, and a murky, anxious future.


Mother Teresa’s Nuns Escape Kabul with Orphans and Show Us How to Live

Mother Teresa on love and faith: Her wisdom remains powerful. It applies to the troubles of our own time.


Ending the Forever War in Afghanistan

Ending the forever war in Afghanistan is good for democracy in the United States.


Pushback on Critical Race Theory Starts with the States

Progressives have spent generations corrupting the education system with anti-American curricula, so a meaningful reversal will take time.


Climate Policy with Chinese Characteristics

Xi Jinping’s emissions-trading scheme shows no indication that it will curb the China’s growing appetite for coal, oil, or natural gas. It was never meant to.


Why the Case for Democrats’ Spending Binge Doesn’t Hold Up

A proper historical comparison for the $3.5 trillion reconciliation bill helps illuminate why the rhetoric used to sell it is so misleading.

Top Stories

Get our conservative analysis delivered right to you. No charge.


Most Popular


Why Don’t We Tell Women What’s Making Them Miserable?


Why Don’t We Tell Women What’s Making Them Miserable?

Most American women with money, degrees, or connections will never hear that our culturally prescribed feminist lifestyle is the source of their unhappiness.


Right on Cue, the President’s Mistakes Are Our Fault Again


Right on Cue, the President’s Mistakes Are Our Fault Again

You know, in a sense, you’re me and I’m you, and all of us are we — and so when the president makes a mistake, it’s really, like the universe …


Biden Subcontracts U.S. Security to Terrorists


Biden Subcontracts U.S. Security to Terrorists

The disastrous U.S.-Taliban ‘partnership’ begins with a massacre.


View More

Read More Feedzy

The Foxhole App - Trusted News Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *