This Day in Liberal Judicial Activism–September 26

uTN Social - Free Speech Social Media

The west side of the Capitol Building in Washington, D.C., August 5, 2021 (Brent Buterbaugh/National Review)

2006–At the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on the nomination of Michael B. Wallace to the Fifth Circuit, Roberta Liebenberg, chair of the ABA’s judicial-evaluations committee, commits multiple acts of apparent flat-out perjury in defending her committee’s “not qualified” rating of Wallace–a rating that resulted from a scandalous process marked by bias, a glaring conflict of interest, incompetence, a stacked committee, the ABA’s violation of its own procedures, and cheap gamesmanship. (See here for documentation.)

2013–A Second Circuit panel (consisting of one Clinton appointee, one Bush 43 appointee, and one Obama appointee) unanimously reverses senior federal district judge Jack B. Weinstein, who had ruled–in a 349-page opinion, with an additional 50+ pages of appendices–that the Eighth Amendment bars applying the statutory minimum five-year term of imprisonment to a youthful defendant who pleaded guilty to one count of distributing child pornography. Unhappy over the reversal, Weinstein within hours issues an extraordinary memorandum arguing that the case “exemplifies the sometimes unnecessary cruelty of our federal criminal law.”

Weinstein, alas, badly obscures the essential facts of the case. He contends in the brief “Facts” section of his memorandum that the defendant “never produced, sold or deliberately exchanged [child] pornography.” (Emphasis added.) But according to the Second Circuit, the defendant admitted that

he had opened a GigaTribe account in November 2008 and used it and another file sharing program, LimeWire, to download “a ton” of child pornography onto the seized computers; and that he had shared child pornography files in designated folders with between 10 and 20 other GigaTribe users. [Emphasis added.]

The Second Circuit’s opinion also includes lots of other very ugly facts (too ugly to repeat here) that would lead very few people to conclude, as Weinstein did, that the defendant’s sentence was unjust.

2016–Federal district judge Algenon L. Marbley (of the Southern District of Ohio) issues a preliminary injunction ordering the Highland Local School District to treat an 11-year-old boy “as the girl she is, including referring to her by female pronouns and her female name and allowing her to use the girls’ restroom.” Never mind that the Supreme Court had just blocked a preliminary injunction in a similar case.

Marbley’s reasoning is laced with errors. For example, on the plaintiff’s Equal Protection claim, he races to find that “transgender status is a quasi-suspect class” subject to heightened scrutiny, but never stops to notice that a bathroom policy that is based on biological sex does not classify on the basis of transgender status.

Recommended


After Altercation at Restaurant, Black Lives Matter Claims NYC Vaccine Mandate Is Being Weaponized

‘Black people are not going to stand by, or you will see another uprising,’ BLM NYC co-founder says at Monday protest.


My Going Maskless Is Different, Says San Francisco Mayor, Because ‘I Was Feeling the Spirit’

Know who else feels the spirit and objects to the fun police? Everybody, that’s who.


Justice Kavanaugh Refuses to Buckle

He had to have known that voting as he did in the Texas case would bring him bad press.


The Real Story in Durham’s Indictment of Democratic Lawyer Michael Sussmann

The special counsel’s final report on the Clinton campaign’s manufacturing of the Trump-Russia collusion narrative will be very interesting reading.


Senator Sinema to Nancy Pelosi: Break Your Word on Infrastructure, and I’m Out

Sinema reportedly has told Joe Biden that she’s aware of the game being played by Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer.


The Real Biden Presidency Emerges

The heroic period of his administration was always a mirage.

The Latest


How Bryson DeChambeau Is Disrupting Golf

With his muscular form and unusual behavior, the young player is bringing some excitement to a typically staid sport.


Return to Middle-earth

A new, expertly edited collection of J. R. R. Tolkien’s writing on his elaborate mythology reminds us of its greatness.


The Gangs of L.A.

A shocking new report suggests that in Los Angeles County, sheriff’s deputies make up some of the most dangerous crime syndicates of all.


How COVID Has Challenged Judaism

The pandemic has meant virtual bar and bat mitzvahs and canceled Birthright trips, leading younger Jews especially to drift from the faith.


Who’s That Living in the Dollhouse?

Patricia Clapp’s King of the Dollhouse is a simple, lovely book that speaks to the secret wish of many a little girl.


What Proponents of Bodily Autonomy Miss

The gratification of our desires must end where the commodification of human beings begins.

Top Stories

Get our conservative analysis delivered right to you. No charge.


Most Popular


Border Patrol Outraged by Biden’s Scapegoating: ‘He Just Started a War’


Border Patrol Outraged by Biden’s Scapegoating: ‘He Just Started a War’

‘I see the administration wants to fry our agents, he just started a war with Border Patrol,’ said one agent.


Biden’s Shameful Attack on Border Patrol


Biden’s Shameful Attack on Border Patrol

Anyone with an interest in the truth knew that no one was whipped in Del Rio almost immediately after this became a trending topic.


CDC’s Rochelle Walensky Overrules Her Own Agency


CDC’s Rochelle Walensky Overrules Her Own Agency

The Biden team doesn’t always ‘follow the science.’


View More

Read More Feedzy

The Foxhole App - Trusted News Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *